Census research: AI-exposed grads face 13 percent lower starting pay
New Census working papers show AI shifted entry-level hiring, dropping starting pay by 13 percent for the most exposed college majors.
Market · Source: U.S. Census Bureau — CES-WP-26-27
What happened
Two working papers from the U.S. Census Bureau reveal exactly how artificial intelligence impacts early career hiring. Researchers looked at administrative data following the release of ChatGPT in late 2022. They found an immediate, sizable, and persistent decrease in hiring for 22 to 24 year olds. This drop happened specifically within the industries most exposed to artificial intelligence.
For the most AI-exposed college majors, the chance of finding an initial job dropped by five percentage points. Full-quarter initial earnings for this group fell by 13 percent. Researchers note this pay drop is massive. They compare it in magnitude to the earnings losses associated with graduating into a large economic recession.
The data shows that companies did not necessarily fire young workers. Instead, they simply stopped hiring them for backfill roles. Employment for early career workers in the most exposed industries declined by 12 percent over 10 quarters. However, the April 2026 paper notes that the hiring rate largely recovered by early 2025 as the overall employment base shrank.
By the numbers
- 13 percent — Decline in full-quarter initial earnings for the most AI-exposed college majors.
- 12 percent — Decline in employment for early career workers in the most AI-exposed industries over 10 quarters.
- 5 percentage points — Drop in the likelihood of initial employment for the most AI-exposed decile of college majors.
Why it matters
The entry-level door has narrowed significantly for recent graduates in fields heavily exposed to AI. Companies are changing how they build their junior workforce. Instead of hiring fresh graduates to do routine tasks, employers are leaving those roles unfilled. They are relying on AI tools to handle the workload. This structural change forces many new graduates to look outside their chosen field to find work.
This shift pushes new graduates into lower-wage sectors of the economy. The September 2026 paper found that about half of the 13 percent earnings decline comes from graduates taking jobs in restaurants and retail. The other half comes from lower earnings within their target industries. While the negative effects lessen as workers gain more experience, the initial hit to their career trajectory is substantial.
Who this hits
New graduates in AI-exposed majors
Your likelihood of securing an initial job in your field is lower today. You may have to accept lower starting pay or look for work in entirely different industries to get started.
Young workers aged 22 to 24
Employment for this age group in the most AI-exposed industries declined by 12 percent over the 10 quarters following the introduction of ChatGPT. However, hiring rates began to stabilize and recover by early 2025 because the total number of these jobs became smaller.
Experienced workers
The data shows that older workers in the same industries did not face the same sudden decline in job gains. The impact of AI adoption is currently concentrated heavily on entry-level hiring rather than senior roles.
What to do this week
- Build real-world projects that show you know how to use AI tools to solve business problems, rather than competing against the technology.
- Target internships, contract roles, or freelance work to get your foot in the door, as companies are hesitant to open traditional full-time junior postings.
- Broaden your job search to industries that are less exposed to AI, where the Census data shows early career hiring has remained stable.
See who's hiring right now on GiraffyReach
My take
I see this data confirming what many new graduates tell me every week. The entry-level market fundamentally changed in late 2022. You cannot just wait for a traditional junior posting anymore. You must show employers exactly how you add value alongside AI.